Connect with us!

For decades, Petey’s NY Pizza, Pastas & Subs has remained a locals’ favorite in downtown Orlando, serving up authentic New York style pizza pies and slices, freshly prepared subs, and perfectly seasoned Italian dishes.

Facebook Twitter

Be the first to get exclusive updates from us!


We would love your support! Please take two minutes and be the first to write a testimonial here!



  • Brian L. Miami, FL

    Petey's is probably the thing I miss most about living in Orlando (sorry family!) When I was living in Colonialtown I ordered from there pretty close to once a week. The first time I went, a little over two years ago, I got the Margherita, because I ...

  • Lauren H. Orlando, FL

    My new favorite pizza place. I've picked up to go several times and last night decided to stay and sit in-house. As someone going to a restaurant alone I often get a server that is rushed and annoyed that I'm taking an entire table for one person ord...

  • Mandi W. Orlando, FL

    It's not often you can stop in at a pizza joint at 10 at night and it be open. And at that time, one would expect to get a slice from a 2 hour old pizza that's been reheated and not exactly great but appeases your temporary hunger. Well, my friends, ...

More reviews >

About Us

Petey's NY Pizza and Subs

Phone (407) 601-6929
Hours Mon, Tue, Wed, Thu: 11:00 am - 10:00 pm
Fri, Sat: 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Sun: 11:00 am - 10:00 pm