Connect with us!

Welcome to Old Time Pizza, providing quality cuisine and service to Port Jefferson Station for over 25 years! Leave the cooking to us and “Buon Appetito”!

Facebook Twitter

Be the first to get exclusive updates from us!


  • “My neighbor, Kristin, turned me on to your food... instant love!”

  • “Great pizza! Reasonable prices!”

  • “I love Old Town Pizza! Best pizza. Best meatballs. Meatball parmesan on toasted garlic bread is my favorite. Best! Best! : ) ”

More testimonials >


Customer Reviews

  • Allister McGuire

    Excellent food, great service. Everyone is very nice and I go here a few times a week

  • Waffle Stomp

    Larry makes a mean pizza, the staff are friendly as well. I recommend this place to everyone.

  • kurt youngberg

    Delicious pizza

More reviews >

About Us

Old Town Pizza

Phone 631 473-3712
Hours Mon, Tue, Wed, Thu, Fri, Sat, Sun: 10:00 am - 10:00 pm