As long as you realize you're in Florida and not someplace else the pizza here is more than acceptable.
Love the pizza.
Love the pizza here! Service is excellent!
See my previous reviews
Loved it! Interesting menu and design of the decorative New York theme. Marquerita pizza, blue cheese salad and meatballs were all excellent. Our servers included the pizza chef and 2 other presenters! I was very impressed by the attentiveness of all the servers. Food quality and presentation were top notch.
Always good ----need more wait staff but the ladies are always smiling and ready to take your order
Very good pizza, prices reasonable, staff is friendly. Quaint little place
IT was DELICIOUS and so much hospitality from the water's.
Took a chance on pizza at a place I've never been or heard of. Pizza was probably one of the best I've ever had. Service was great too.
The best pizza I've ever had.
Best pizza in The Villages area.
It was recommended to be.. Stopped in for their Garlic Knots, mild wings & a meaty pizza. All very good. The staff was very attentive & friendly. I want to go back for a Calzone soon. You guys let me know what you think...
Very, Very good...😁😁😁
I can't figure out how this place would warrant any less than 5 stars. Absolutely the best Stromboli I have had and it is not even close. Crust was perfect, the cheese was excellent(I was told it was from New York), and the spinach was fresh. Very good marinara sause. It was so big I had to take half home with me. Tried the garlic knots and thet were also very good. Service could not have been better. I want to thank Lauren for making it such a pleasant experience. I will definitely be back when I am in the area!
We actually had NYPD Pizza cater a funeral lunch and it could not have gone better. Short on time, and reeling from the upheaval, we found their catering menu online. It was comprehensive and made us think maybe a pizza place could do the catering. We met with Lauren who could not have been kinder. The owner, Gary, and the servers who came to the lunch handled everything perfectly. The food was delicious (the lasagna was a hit), my mother was pleased, and the day went off without a hitch. I would recommend NYPD Pizza as a catering option.
Good pizza good and friendly service. Dose get crowded some times.
Traditional NYC Neopolitan Pizza
Great pizza and best wings in the area!!
WOW what great food. My wife and I were craving a calzone and NYPD did not disappoint. Service was fast, friendly. Clean and comfy environment. The calzones are very large and will be another meal for us. Enjoy!!