As we've tried many places AJ's was a success on rocket day! We didn't call ahead and make a reservation but got a table right away, much to our surprise because the place was packed. Service was quick and very sweet Megan was on point with EVERYTHING! I had the grilled tuna and my wife had a Delmonico. Both dishes were amazing, hats off to the chef. We followed by cocktails and entertainment in the lounge. The barmaid welcomed us right away with a smile. Overall our whole experience was excellent. AJ's is a must do on Chincoteague!
Ken was our waiter and you could not find someone better. We had 6 appetizers and they were all delicious. The Delmonico steak was out of the world as was the filet mignon. Highly recommend you stop if you are on the island.
Looking for great seafood, this is the place. The seafood bouillabaisse is awesome. Extremely Kid friendly.
Best meal so far on chincoteage island. Filet melts in mouth. Great oyster Rockefeller. Our waiter Ken P was the best. So witty and service was quick. Will definitely go back
Best place on the island for a date in my opinion.
Had a very nice lunch. Beautiful River view. Our server, Stephany did a great job! Love the fried shrimp! Very fresh and lightly fried.
Love their food. Owners are amazing
Awesome atmosphere and service. Ambience was perfect!!!
Celebrated Anniversary with delicious foods. Wide variety of seafood choices. Well executed and presented. It is pricey, but good value for higher, fresh quality. Server, Megan, very attentive. Call for reservations especially during tourist season. Full bar with friendly staff. Ask for Ruby for her great smile & potions of brew. Nice decor. Evening service white linens. Extremely nice atmosphere. Dress up or go informal, but definitely treat it as special!!
Food was very good. Excellent selection. Servers were excellent and full of personality. We were made to feel like regulars even though this was our first time. We will definitely come back.
We stopped by on a rainy Friday with no preconceptions. We were delightfully surprised by the prices. The sign said â€œfine dining,â€ so we figured the prices would match. The waiter, Kenneth, was attentive and gracious. Our food arrived quickly and was delicious. I had the best seafood scampi everâ€” it wasnâ€™t drowning in butter, but the flavors were delicate and scrumptious. My companion has the crabcakes which were golden on the outside and tender without being soggy. Once again, the chef managed to prepare the food to perfection. I would return in a heartbeat.
My sisters bday weekend was a blast thanks to Kat! There were 6 of us in our group along with a full bar on Saturday, March 23. Kat always takes great care of us...& the bloody Maryâ€™s were the best Iâ€™ve ever had!!
Food delicious, staff very friendly, off season so no crowds. Shrimp scampi so flavorful and different, mahi in mango sauce delicious, not informed it was blackened, but loved it because it was.
Food was good , portions were great , service was fast and friendly. Good value
It's very good seafood but it's very expensive. Worth it though
Amazing food and even better service from Jan!!. She was great
Wonderful service. Yummy food!
The first evening on the new season. Cosy restaurant with a buzzy atmosphere.....I chose the Bouillabaisse and my husband had the seafood pasta...both totally delicious. The bar lady made excellent Old Fashioned cocktails. Great service too. Thank you, we shall return
Un peu de classe et le homard sera bien servi! Un peu plus chÃ¨re que la moyenne mais l'ambiance feutrÃ©e vous transporte ailleur! Vous n'Ãªtes plus sur une Ã®le oÃ¹ presque mais dans un Resto sur la cÃ´te d'azur sans avoir les bleus!! Du crabe a carapace mole et des palourdes et on dit merci!!!
Ended up here by default (the 2 places recommended to us were full/closed) and I am glad we did. Very nice food.