We had a fabulous meal here. It was my wife’s birthday and we wanted to try a new spot on the island. Appetizers were great. Entrees were in believable. We both had seafood. It was sensational and so very fresh. The grilled seafood was the BEST, but it was all delicious.
Great menu. Food was very good and wait staff was excellent
The menu had seafood with local fish & shellfish. My wife had Smothered Flounder, which had crab & shrimp over it,she recommends it & will get it the next time we go back. Since I don't eat fish I got the Rack of Lamb, which was seasoned very well & didn't need any S&P or mint jelly. It comes with 2 or 4 racks, I had 4 but 2 is good. In season they have a screened it porch to dine on. Ken was our waiter who was helpful & new the foods very well, he even let me try a wine to see if I liked it.
I ordered the bouillabaisse. It was all good but the scallops were amazing! Next t8me I will focus on scallops. Nice wine choices too. Lovely service!
Food was good. Except for the onion rings. Hopefully it was just that day.
The Seafood Scampi was delicious. I tend to be leery of eating seafood at new places, but I was pleasantly surprised to discover the succulent scallops and shrimp prepared for me. It was exactly what I was searching for on my trip. I recommend stopping by to sample the menu.
Great food, calm environment. We had been on the beach all morning and were ready for some good food. Cream of crab soup was great. My husband loved his oysters and the key lime pie was perfection! Margeret was a great server who attended to our every need.
We visited on April 24th. Probably our best meal on the island! A lot better service and food than the place across the street.... Steaks and seafood were great, and atmosphere was calm and enjoyable. Our server was a gentleman - can't remember his name, but he was very attentive.
First time ever to Chincoteague, Great atmosphere, food is fantastic, service was excellent. Ask for Jan! She made us feel welcome and like we have been coming here for years!
We had our last night's dinner here and were very pleased. The food was excellent and the service wonderful.
Excellent food, cozy atmosphere, they even have a little nook with a privacy curtain for a romantic date night. Great place
Great fresh seafood and attentive service
Fine all around dining in an intimate setting.
Spring was quite obvious looking out of big windows. Great lunch very reasonable prices. Most places in Chincoteague were closed so we were very happy to find AJ s open with full menu.
A little afraid we we're not dressed appropriately for the "fine dining" on their sign...but it is a friendly, casual atmosphere...and the food very good!! The house dressing, an artichoke viniagrette was just right on a fresh salad. The crab cakes were awesome, as was my husband's ceasar salad and mahi mahi entree. Enjoyable...would gladly go back again.
Love to come in when Kat is working..she is the bomb bartender..sweet..kind..and the best at her job!
Food is great!!
This is a must do when you come to Chincoteague! The food is EXCEPTIONAL! Definitely recommend the Shrimp Scampi Pasta, Oysters Romanoff, Oysters Rockefeller, and Clams Casino!
The seafood scampi was out of this world - scallops cooked to perfection- and then chef gave us a scrumptious chocolate dessert to end a perfect meal. Servings were generous, food presentation on point and service was great too! We had the screened in porch overlooking the creek to ourselves - others were seated inside- they missed out on one of the best things about this place. AJâ€™s lived up to its reputation! Donâ€™t miss this!
Great seafood. Had the Seafood Bouillabaisse it was one of the best things I ever ate. The oysters Rockefeller were very good to.