Great spot for a fresh bagel. Little bit of a wait on Sundays. The staff is super cool.
Had a 4am pitstop at Bagelsmith and did not regret it. The bagel-maid was just adorable and even let us use the toilet. I went for the sundried tomatoes and tofu on an everything bagel. Highly recommend that. Food 5/5 Service 5/5 Atmosphere 3/5 Bagel is back!
Sundried Tomato Basil AF
Love the nr 1 on the menu 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽 Love from norway ❤️
Fantastic bagels and sandwiches. It's usually busy but the service is quick
Wonderful staff and amazing Bagels, great selection of cream cheeses. What more can you ask?
My favorite bagel shop in Brooklyn! Bagels are delicious and there is a large variety of tofu cream cheese
Wow! I love it! Sesame and scallion cream cheese says hello and party time.
Egggcellent bagels, mediocre coffee
Bagel is awesome but The spread is a bit too salty.
Délicieux bagels, le n°2 au poulet est top!
Wonderful whitefish. Can't go wrong
Some of the best everything bagels that I’ve ever had! A must-try for those in and around Brooklyn.
Good bagels. Terrible line at any hour. Worth it though. The women who run the cash register are the best. Just don’t go late morning on a weekend if you are claustrophobic.
What a brilliant name for a bagel shop. Essentially creating a whole new word. The bagels are truly delicious, but the homemade cream cheese is what stole the show. Still have dreams about it.
Best bagel I have ever had. The homemade cream cheese was amazing. I wish I had one right now!
Who doesnt' love a great bagel? The bagel was decent, not great but decent. AS for the service it was above par. The prices for drinks are just a little bit on the high side which forced me to walk down to Whole Foods and purchase a drink their. Other than that its a bagel place, nothing to create long lines as the bagels come out the oven,.
Seriously missing your cream cheese salmon bagels since I left NYC!
Great service. Nice bagel.
Outstanding selection of sandwiches, staff is smiling despite being busy pretty much all the time.